When I saw this, it reminded me of a seminar I attended in the mid-nineties. I was a consulting marine engineer – however many of the attendees were master mariners and mates. The seminar centred on the very high level of maritime insurance claims and reviewed research carried out at the time that suggested some 78% of all major maritime insurance claims could be attributed to human error. During one session of the seminar dealing with the subject of collisions – I dared to ask the question, half-jokingly ‘With such a high incidence of human error, why not simply remove all personnel from the ships and operate them remotely’? – There followed loud guffaws of laughter in the room. It seems that the same may not be quite the case tomorrow? – JKA chair/webmaster
Here a small slice of maritime history which I thought to write down about St Helena the tiny remote UK Protectorate Island in the South Atlantic.
Some of you will know the island, will know Jamestown the capital and the background, but there is an unbelievable modern day twist to the tale.
Although a much visited and vital staging post for sailing ships voyaging via The Cape of Good Hope between Europe and the Far East, in 1815 the island of St Helena was regarded as so remote and so destitute of amenity that it was chosen as the most secure and suitable location to incarcerate Napoleon for the second time after he supposedly “escaped” from Elba. After several years in residence the troublesome celebrity died and was buried there surrounded by controversy and accusations of arsenic poisoning, but in a spirit of reconciliation with the French, his body was eventually exhumed and taken to Paris for a state burial.
The Honorable East India Company who effectively governed the island and who clearly relied on it for provisioning their ships, in 1814 commissioned and built the first ship to bear the name St Helena, a 136 ton schooner designed to supply and provision the island from her home port in the UK, from Cape Town, and from various other locations on the West African coast, with a wide range of cargo and passengers, but predominantly livestock in an attempt to make the island community more self sufficient and less reliant on support from Europe. She was not a lucky ship at times surrounded by controversy, losing captains and missing the island altogether with a cargo of livestock which never reached their intended destination on at least one occasion, but was employed in this valuable service until 1830 when she was attacked by pirates. Shortly after that the Company decided to sell her on; thus ending the 16 year association with the island, she being wrecked whilst trading on the South African coast in Plettenberg Bay in 1851.
Without the support of the schooner the island had to rely on support from what had become a substantial number of ships passing including the Royal Navy which fortunately took a greater share of the responsibility, bearing in mind the presence of substantial military garrisons in Jamestown as well as on Ascension Island. Such was the volume of traffic in the South Atlantic at that time that together with Greenwich, Cape Town, and Sydney, even St Helena warranted a “Time Ball” being installed and dropped from it’s staff at 1.00 pm Greenwich time every day so ships in visual contact could check their ship’s chronometers as an aid to accurate navigation.
With the opening of the Suez Canal in 1863 (or thereabouts!) the island was less frequented as a staging post except for ships en route to and from the UK and her growing Dominion of South Africa, such as the Union Line which in the late Victorian era became the celebrated Union Castle Line passenger fleet, which had the benefit of a Royal Mail contract to carry the mail between the UK and South Africa. In addition however Union Castle apparently had a tradition if not an obligation to support St Helena by calling there regularly en route north and south with vital provisions and to collect and transport the island’s only industry and export in the form of bales of sisal milled on the island from the flax growing almost wild there, to be shipped to Dundee for rope making, and to make mail bags and string for the Royal Mail. An important contract and source of income for the island.
This support by Union Castle and other well established large passenger liners calling there continued for almost 100 years, the islanders relying wholly on these often unscheduled visits for all their supplies; but with the general demise of the world’s passenger fleet services in the 1970s and no possible airport connection, the future of the islanders looked decidedly bleak until in 1977 the UK government stepped in to fill the gap by funding a vital lifeline in the form of a reasonable sized robust general cargo carrier suitably equipped with the necessary cargo handling gear, and with a history of providing support to remote settlements in Alaska, modified to take a limited number of passengers, and renamed RMS St Helena, the RMS denoting she was to carry the Royal Mails.
The “RMS” as she was called plied between her UK home port, Las Palmas, Ascension Island, St Helena, Cape Town, and occasionally Tristan de Cunha giving vital service and support to these remote locations until the Falklands War in 1982 when much to the concern of the island populations she was commandeered by the UK military for support services in South Georgia and the Falklands war zone.
A replacement was provided in the form of M V Centaur on a short term charter, designed primarily by her owners Blue Funnel as a cattle carrier with substantial passenger accommodation (which seems an unlikely combination) but this was a temporary arrangement and with the commandeered RMS retained in the service of the military after the Falklands war ended, it became clear that there was a need for a purpose designed vessel to support the three island communities.
Ascension, the nearest land mass to St Helena but still over 1,000 km distant, by this time had had the benefit of a substantial military air base for 50 years or more, and many “Saints” (as residents of St Helena are called) had found employment on the base, two weeks on and two week off, being ferried back and forth between the two islands by the RMS; and they particularly and the other island communities in general were anxious that communication between their home and their work place was put on a sure footing, so their lobby for a permanent purpose designed replacement was loud and clear.
For all sorts of very valid reasons, not least the volcanic mountainous terrain on St Helena and it’s remoteness from other landing strips in an emergency, an airport was then out of the question.
Another unexpected blow to the economy of the island at about this time was the sudden and devastating termination of the contract to supply the Royal Mail with the only export of the island; the bales of sisal which for years had sustained a “sizable” (excuse the pun!) proportion of the workforce. A decision by the UK Civil Service and the Royal Mail to dispense with natural fiber mail bags and twine or string, unbelievably in favour of synthetic material and elastic rubber bands sealed the fate of not only the flax plantations but also the mills. Whether the civil servant decision makers in the UK responsible were even aware of the consequences of their questionable decision is uncertain, but it understandably caused a great deal of resentment.
By the late 1980s agreement had been reached for the UK government to finance the construction of a purpose built supply vessel with general cargo and container capability and accommodation for in excess of 150 passengers to service the island communities, and November 1990 saw the maiden voyage of the brand new RMS St Helena, having been built by Hall Russel in Aberdeen, and the third commercial vessel to bear that name.
She sailed out of her home port Cardiff, and in 1999 after nearly 10 years of her being in service I was privileged to be a passenger to Cape Town to celebrate the millennium there, calling at Las Palmas alongside, Ascension Island anchored, and also anchored in James Bay for two days spending the whole time ashore in Jamestown and being driven round the island in a 1930s wooden bodied motor char-a-banc which is still running to this day. Made so welcome by everybody, an absolutely fascinating two days on the island, as was life on board for the three week voyage, with the captain and purser (who were ex Union Castle), and crew entering into the spirit of the voyage by recreating life as it had been on board the Union Castle Liners, with Union Castle dinner menus, cocktail parties, film shows, hilarious after dinner games, and of course the traditional Crossing the Line Ceremony.
During this my first visit to the island there was serious debate at that time of surmounting the difficulties and building an airport, to replace the RMS when she ended her service, but the island population and the visitors were divided in their thoughts, the younger population keen to travel backwards and forwards to their work at the military base on Ascension by air rather than take a couple of days by ship, and of course easier access to the rest of the world, and others who wished to preserve the very special status quo and limit the huge growth in tourism and the type of visitor which would result from making the island easily accessible from such tourist hot spots as Cape Town.
At about this time a sensible decision was taken to move the home port of the RMS from the UK to Cape Town, thus avoiding the long run up and down the North Atlantic, confined to the South Atlantic making better use of her time sailing back and forth from Cape Town to St Helena to discharge supplies and some tourists and pick up additional passengers…. the Saints who were on call for a two week stint at the military base; then on to Ascension to disembark one work force and embark those going home for a spell. Once a year I think, a call was made to Tristan de Cunha.
With the RMS starting to age, some time about 2010 and despite the difficulties of finding a suitable site for a runway the airport lobby was at its height, and I believe the UK government made a deal with the island officials to fund the construction of a passenger jet quality airport in return for discontinuing the financial support which the Protectorate had been receiving for years, on the basis that tourist income would expand dramatically, replace UK government support, thereby making them self sufficient and independent. (Whether they wanted to be or not!)
I was so taken with the island on my first visit; when over the period 2014/2016 I was planning to spend the two winters and travel to Cape Town by sea I deliberately chose to travel on ships calling at St Helena; the Astor, two visits, on her way to and from Australia operated by Cruise & Maritime Voyages, and a third visit on Voyager owned by Voyages of Discovery.
Making what was in fact my fourth visit to the island, three within the previous18 months, walking up the main street of Jamestown to my amazement I was recognised by not one but two of the local residents which really made my day as you can imagine.
All three visits the main talking point was the ongoing construction of the airport and what changes were in hand on the island to support its construction and to accommodate the huge changes expected in the tourism and hospitality business. My last visit made mid April 2016 was little more that 4 to 6 weeks before the airport was due to be operational, and there was a feeling of great expectation mixed with apprehension. Although not the last ship to visit before the airport was open, my visit was supposed to be one of the last, as I gathered that by end of May this year there would be daily flights from Cape Town and Namibia, and to and from Ascension as well, and the RMS would be taken out of service.
I couldn’t help but feel that huge changes were on their way and unfortunately those changes might not be for the better. For it takes a certain type of person with interests and the patience to be prepared to give up several weeks of their life on board a ship there and back in order to visit and experience the island, and a different type of visitor entirely who is only prepared to spend a few hours on a plane to make that same journey.
The RMS was advertising a programme of “last” cruise visits to the island before she was to be retired and sold or scrapped after the airport was opened and operational.
Here we are in August three months after the airport was supposed to be operational with planes and passengers in and out….However I have just heard all has changed, and the RMS will now continue as before servicing St Helena and Ascension Island from Cape Town for at least the next twelve months.
Apparently, that because of frequent adverse weather conditions and frequent cross winds experienced at the site of the airport (which incidentally has cost the British taxpayer £250 million) and because in the event of these adverse conditions no safe landing is possible, there is no alternative airport other than Ascension which is too far distant at over 1000km, the facility does not (and it would seem cannot!) comply with International Passenger Flight Safety Regulations, and as a result so far, I believe a license to operate has been refused!!!!!!!!!!
So the demise of the RMS has apparently been postponed until at least May 2017!!!!!!!!!
Watch this space!
Some pictures attached.
1) A model of the very first St Helena, a sloop owned by the Honorable East India Company
2 &3) A painting and a commemorative stamp issue of Union Line’s RMS Scot which held the record for the shortest time between the UK and Cape Town from the 1890s after she was lengthened for nearly 30 years, and which supported the two island communities
4) The first RMS St Helena. A lifeline for many years until she was commandeered to support the Falklands invasion. 5) The second (and final?) RMS St Helena which has been in service since 1990, and which has had a stay of execution until May 2017, with the first RMS alongside astern of her.
6) James Bay and Jamestown on a good day with the church tower just visible.
To the best of my knowledge all correct but with my apologies for any inaccuracies or errors!!!